Get the Free Country California E-Book

Peter Cooper of The Tennessean says Fake News is "something like country music’s version of farcical newspaper The Onion, or like an all-country online cousin to The Daily Show." Join our mailing list and we'll send you an immediate (free!) e-book download, featuring some of our favorite Fake News stories of the past four years.

Sugarland Got It Right… Almost

I complain when an artist puts out an expanded version of an existing album to boost sales – I’m looking at you, Blake Shelton – so it only seems right that I should praise Sugarland for doing the opposite.

The deluxe fan edition of Love on the Inside was released today, and it contains 5 bonus tracks that will not be on the standard release next Tuesday. Which begs the question: Who will wait an extra week to get an album with 5 fewer songs? Probably the same people who paid QVC $20+ to have Randy Travis’ new album shipped to them eventually rather than picking it up at Target on release day for $8. But I digress.

Sugarland’s inventive release strategy introduces a new (to me, at least) phenomenon: the shrinking album.* The earlier you buy, the more album you get. I like that. It’s a refreshing change from the expanding album (“If You’re Reading This” added to Let It Go), which puts its earliest buyers at a disadvantage a few months down the road when the album comes out again, bigger and better. Do you suck it up and buy the album again? Just buy the added tracks? Either way, you’re probably paying more than the casual straggler who happens upon the album for the first time in its expanded version.

So, kudos to Sugarland for rewarding those who rush out to buy the album as soon as it hits stores. It’s a nice gesture that should pay off handsomely for them in album sales and good will.

I just wish they had pushed the concept even further. I’m guessing that the deluxe edition will still be available next Tuesday when the standard edition comes out, so even the semi-hardcore fans will have the option of buying the longer album. That’s not fair. As a purchaser of the deluxe fan edition – which makes me, if I understand this correctly, a deluxe fan – I want my investment and status protected. How many copies of the deluxe edition are there? How long will they be available? I don’t want them in the hands of just anyone. I demand answers.

If it were up to me, the deluxe edition would cease to be available next Monday at 11:59pm. Everyone buying the album on July 29 would have to settle for 12 tracks. Sorry… you had your chance. It wouldn’t stop there, either. The album would continue shrinking. On the one-year anniversary of the album’s release, all remaining standard copies would be swept from the shelves and it would be reissued in an 11-track version. (“All I Want To Do” would be removed. Thank me later.) On 7/29/10, it would be reissued in a 10-track version. This would continue every year. By 2019, it would be down to one song, which would necessarily be the “Very Last Country Song.” After that? Implosion.

Okay, that was a little far-fetched. Sorry. I’m just steamed because I don’t have the golden ticket.

* Before anyone mentions it, I’m familiar with retailer-specific exclusives released concurrently with an album… but an expanded version released everywhere before the standard album? That’s new to me.

SHARE Twitter | Facebook + SUBSCRIBE Email | RSS

About C.M. Wilcox

A freelance writer and humorist with an abiding love of country music, C.M. Wilcox's cutting, clear-eyed take on the genre has drawn the attention of Country Weekly, The Washington Post, and The Tennessean in the years since this site began. He lives near Sacramento and can be reached by email at CMW (at)

Things People Are Saying

  1. Dan M. says:

    This post…is awesome.

  2. Leeann says:

    Excellent points! I would hope that as the songs dwindled with each progressing week, the price would also decrease as well?

    I totally agree that it is frustrating that fans who rush out to buy their artists’ albums are so often rewarded by being expected to throw down another $13 for the extra tracks if they want them. They should at least do what Sugarland has done or release the two additions at the same time…or even better, hold those songs for another album or just put the dang things on in the first place.

  3. John Maglite says:

    Since it’s my fantasy, no, the album price would go up as the number of tracks decreased. Sort of how this 13-track version of Let It Go is inexplicably $29 more than this 14-track version.

  4. Leeann says:

    Ah, okay, I’m with ya now. I should have guessed it in the first place. You snooze, you lose, Sucker!:)

  5. Blake Boldt says:

    Realistic, no. Hilarious, yes. I'm just sorry it took me so long to read this.

    I do agree with this —> If it were up to me, the deluxe edition would cease to be available next Monday at 11:59pm.

  6. J.R. Journey says:

    I really like paragraph five …

  7. Anonymous says:

    I’m already gonna have to buy all my favorite movies again on Blu-Ray eventually, so why do I wanna have to buy my favorite albums twice too? Duh. Sugarland had a genius idea.

Speak Your Mind


Comment Policy: Just don't be too big of a jerk, okay? It's a pretty simple rule.